Another Short Answer

(A free-write reflection in response to reading a sister’s answer.)

I’m in the SPEAK! project, and I almost didn’t want to be. I was scared, and it was going on during a time I felt scared of everything. Even my shadow was maligning. I panicked when I remembered I said I would contribute. At that point, most of the other contributors attended last year’s AMC and recorded theirs in a studio. I only had the built-in microphone on my laptop. I tried test recordings, just saying words, and the shakiness of my voice made me cry. The crying made my voice break and tremble even more before I abandoned it for the night.

The next day I tried again, and this time I took Deep Breaths. Will record this poem. Will send it away to CD Land. Gonna do it, gonna do it… I took one big giant breath, and I blazed through the poem I wrote shortly after erasing my previous blog. I sent it off after listening to it once and I sent it to my co-blogger. I’d promised. I wrote that poem when I felt tired of absorbing blows, tired of expectations to plow through painful ordeal after painful ordeal. My voice felt weary and broken speaking about every injustice that crossed my path, and when I started feeling physically ill, emotionally ill, mentally unstable I didn’t ask myself, “Why am I in so much pain?” I asked, “Does this make me a bad friend? A bad blogger? A bad writer? A bad activist? A bad feminist? A bad black woman? A bad person? Why am I becoming so weak?”

So weak. So down. So blinded to the sunshine and energy surrounding me.

I’ve never had a chance to try to understand pain or hurt in my life. Writing in journals, blogs, notebooks — my writing is my main exploratory avenue for understanding and learning from pain and failure. Throughout traumatic experiences in my personal world, I’ve always had to take one for the team. Be strong. Help fight. Stand up and move. Care for people. But I’d be lying if I said these actions — now instinctive — were what I truly desired to do. And sometimes I think I take it for granted that everyone faces tasks that she may not wish to do. Everyone faces situations that she would rather avoid. But what happens when you feel dragged through these tasks and situations unnecessarily? What happens when you wind up in certain situations because someone haphazardly carries you there and abandons you?

BA’s entry then led me to understand why I couldn’t get upset. It wasn’t that I was incapable of being upset or invulnerable. But often when the youngest of a group or gathering gets upset or expresses some inclination of hurt or pain, it sends a current of fear through the entire group. Never be young and sense that something is wrong. Never let on that you know something’s wrong. When the youngest of the gathering starts to feel pain, it adds to the collective pain of the group. It’s easier to tell someone to fight when you can’t explain why they were wronged. It’s easier to tell someone to move than it is to sit and let them sort things out. This fighting culture has no time for exploration, for healing, for understanding the true sources of pain and energy. This fighting culture only has time to make pain stop so you can stand up and keep fighting for… what? Crumbs? Coins? Ideas? You fight, you fall, you get up — on and on and on until what happens? Where exactly will our fights lead?

I struggle more with hurt and pain than I should. I admit that freely. I am an Over Thinker as well as an Over Sharer. I grew up for so long in such a cloistered-off space where I couldn’t talk about anything, lest I betray something or someone or some place or some idea. But what happens when the thoughts and questions in my head have nowhere else to go? Even the most banal activities keep me fascinated because they are so minute, yet so integral to daily life. I’d like to paint myself as a warrior princess, a drum major for justice, or something equally combative and noble. But honestly, I’m just a person. Can’t I enjoy that, explore that, stay in that without pursuing your dreams and your hopes? Does my desire to do that indicate there’s something wrong with me or with you?

Do you trust that I’ll come through after I take time to heal myself?

About problem chylde
"In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths." Proverbs 3:6

8 Responses to Another Short Answer

  1. ilyka says:

    This fighting culture has no time for exploration, for healing, for understanding the true sources of pain and energy.

    Truer words.

    I struggle more with hurt and pain than I should.

    The only sense in which I think that may be true is this: You’ve been subjected to hurtful and painful things more than you should have been. But how you deal is how you deal. There is no “should,” although God knows I put that word on myself all the time too, first because I was taught to and later because I learned well enough to do it myself.

    Now can I get giddy because OMG SYLVIA/M IS ON THE SPEAK CD, I DIDN’T EVEN KNOW?!? So excited to get this!

  2. Sylvia/M says:

    Hee, yes. I’m on there; I did a piece. :) And I guess I feel like I’m in a bind because I want to be that strong person at times. I feel sometimes I’m obligated to play that role. But then I wonder who’s holding me up? When do I stop to acknowledge my back is nearly broken? And the answer for that route seems to be I don’t acknowledge it.

  3. Nanette says:

    And I guess I feel like I’m in a bind because I want to be that strong person at times. I feel sometimes I’m obligated to play that role.

    You can’t hold anyone else up if your back is almost broken. It took me far too long to learn that – I never really had or took the time to stop and think and feel what I needed to, when I needed to. No need for others to make the same mistake ;) . Nor would I (still don’t, am working on it) allow others to help or to see that I needed or wanted comfort, or was being anything but a strong, Black woman making every day the best ever, blah blah blah.

    It’s perfectly okay to take care of yourself, to allow yourself to feel the pain and, if it’s there, despair. Wrap yourself in something soft and warm, grab some tissues (and a pint of ice cream, yay!), a good book or some music or your laptop and just have at it.

  4. Nanette says:

    It wasn’t that I was incapable of being upset or invulnerable. But often when the youngest of a group or gathering gets upset or expresses some inclination of hurt or pain, it sends a current of fear through the entire group. Never be young and sense that something is wrong. Never let on that you know something’s wrong. When the youngest of the gathering starts to feel pain, it adds to the collective pain of the group.

    It’s interesting, if a bit distressing, that you feel that way. Mind, I’m rarely part of a group at all for very long, but whether I am or not, I tend to keep my ears and eyes open to the pain or fear or anger of the younger folks, as well as the joy and happiness, of course – online, you and Sydette as the youngest I know – not because you (general) cannot take care of yourselves, or deal with things yourselves (although sometimes that is the case) but because I am quite a bit older and have had to put up with stuff so long, I feel that I can be somewhat um… inured to various things. Or maybe just tired ;)

    So anyway, I don’t see the expression of those feelings of pain or hurt, vulnerability or whatever as a burden or a distraction but more as a weathervane or a prod – an impetus to (if I can figure out where I put my bat) come out swinging instead of just shaking my head and walking away.

    Which thing, mind you, I also reserve the right and necessity to do.

  5. Over-thinker, maybe. Over-sharer? NO. Why do you think so?

    Again, a difference I perceive among white vs WOC bloggers: An apology for sharing, for talking too much. Meanwhile, the people who are truly self-indulgent and DO talk too much, never apologize or even worry about “over-sharing”–even when they clearly ought to. Think about it.

    This stuff is on my mind today–the “different standards for different people” phenomenon. We tend to take it for granted, but I get very obsessive whenever I see it.

    Love ya, your blog, your over-thinking, your work. ((kisses))

  6. MadamaAmbi says:

    hi Sylvia–I relate to what you’ve written about struggling with hurt and pain and yet wanting to be strong, and wondering if you’re helping yourself with the “overthinking” and the “oversharing…”

    I’ve been there and done that, bigtime. There are no shortcuts, imo. But, what I want to say to you, sister to sister, is that YOU GET TO DECIDE. It’s for you to decide if how you share is ok with YOU, if how you process your pain is working for YOU, and for you to value your pain, your struggle and your victories. For you to decide what your victories are.

    Obviously, you’re also a writer, so you’re going to write about your internal process, and link it to the world you live in. When you go public, people will criticize, people will applaud, people will ignore you…there’s no end to the commentary you will receive on what you put out there. But YOU get to decide if you want to internalize it or even listen to it.

    love
    Madama

  7. Skeletor says:

    “Even the most banal activities keep me fascinated because they are so minute, yet so integral to daily life. I’d like to paint myself as a warrior princess, a drum major for justice, or something equally combative and noble. But honestly, I’m just a person. Can’t I enjoy that, explore that, stay in that without pursuing your dreams and your hopes? Does my desire to do that indicate there’s something wrong with me or with you?”

    God, no, you’re not a bad person, activist, blogger, or any of that. You’re undeniably human, caring, and forceful enough to put your thoughts into words that don’t dissolve into complete hatred or despair, such as, “Well fuck you!” Shit, that’s what draws me to this blog.

    Everyone cries. It sounds simple and trite, but why the hell would we have tear glands and the compulsion, if we never did cry?

    Warrior princesses are nice but what of the rest of us? It seems hard to obtain, from my stand point, the status of the never-failing, tough-as-nails, whoop-ass warrior that sacrifices and sacrifices. It seems like a top percentile that, even if achieved, would leave the rest of us as less than worthy, and that just can’t be.

    It reminds me of Alice Childress’ play, “Wine in the Wilderness,” where the man was painting that triptych of the African American woman, but on the left was the innocent child, in the middle was the beautiful woman sitting in the wilderness like a goddess of beauty, and he’d reserved the right side for the common girl that had been kicked so many times in the behind that she could barely get up. She’s not realistic, the goddess in the center; she’s some mythical… I don’t know, but I don’t like it for any woman.

    Don’t fault yourself for being a beautiful human with all our shortcomings. I know this post is old, but…

    We do the very best with what we’re given, and you’ve done that.

  8. Pingback: The Things We Earn « Raven’s Eye

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 113 other followers